Evaluation
You found this Infosheet to be:
|
![]() Éducaloi is a non-profit organization whose mission is to inform Quebecers of their rights and obligations by providing quality legal information in everyday language.
La loi vos droits
Clientele : Parents
Subject : Same Sex Parents and the Law
Print date : February 7th, 2012
Parents
Manon and Rachida are two women who have been living together for 5 years. They want to have a child together. They are wondering if the fact that they are a same-sex couple will affect their choice to have a child and their status as "parents". For example, if Rachida gives birth to the couple’s child, what will Manon’s status be? Will she be considered a parent?
In this Infosheet, Éducaloi explains the concept of filiation when the parents are a same-sex couple.
In law, filiation is the family relationship that unites a child to his or her parents.
It is one of the most important relationships that exists between 2 individuals. Being the mother or father of a child means making the important decisions that affect him, taking care of his education and his needs. To learn more about this relationship, read our Infosheet entitled Filiation: the legal link between parents and children.
The law only recognizes three types of filiation:
Filiation cannot be based only on the psychological bond that exists between a child and an adult. To learn more about filiation, consult our Infosheet Filiation: the legal link between parents and children.
A parental project is the decision to have a child by using the sperm or egg of another person. That other person must intervene to give his sperm or her egg but his or her participation ends there.
Here are a few examples:
It all depends on whether or not you formed a “parental project” with your girlfriend before getting pregnant. If you and your girlfriend formed a “parental project”, she can claim filiation on that basis with the child, once it is born.
However, if you had no parental project with your girlfriend when you got pregnant, you will have to see if she can adopt your child once it is born. Otherwise, your girlfriend will have no filiation with the child. For more information about adoption, consult our Infosheet Adopting a child in Quebec.
There are four ways of proving filiation:
Establishing filiation gives the mother’s partner the same rights and duties as the mother. To find out more about this topic, read our Infosheet entitled Filiation: the legal link between parents and children.
No. Psychological parenthood is not recognized by the law. Whether a couple is same-sex (including a couple composed of 2 men) or heterosexual, it makes no difference. Filiation does not come about by the feelings or the relationship that exists between the adult and the child.
For example, Stephanie moves in with Roxanne and her 1 year old son, James. Although Stephanie treats James as her son in every way and James calls her “mommy”, 10 years down the road, she will still not be recognized by the law as James’ mother. Stephanie does not have any filiation with James. If Stephanie wants to be recognized as James’s mother, she should adopt James. She may not be able to adopt James if he already has a father or a second mother. For information about the conditions that must be met to adopt a child in Quebec, consult our Infosheet Adopting a child in Quebec. Remember that the law does not allow a child to have more than 2 parents. The fact that there is no filiation between the adult playing a parenting role in the child’s life and the child does not mean that the law will ignore the bonds that were created. See the following questions for details: “Can custody be given to someone other than the parents?” in our Infosheet Child custody; “Who can obtain access rights to a child?” in our Infosheet Exercising access rights; “I have a new spouse. Does he have obligations toward my children?” in our Infosheet Frequently asked questions about child support.
Currently, the only ways that two men can be legally recognized as the parents of a child involve adoption. More specifically:
They can’t form a “parental project” because it would involve using a surrogate mother. An agreement with a surrogate mother is invalid in Quebec. A surrogate mother is a woman who agrees to lend her womb to carry the baby. Sometimes, she also furnishes the eggs necessary to conceive the child. Once she delivers the baby, she gives it over to the people who retained her services. Since the law does not acknowledge the agreement between the surrogate mother and the two men, the filiation of the child will be with the person who gave birth to him, i.e. the surrogate mother, and with his biological father. To learn more about surrogate mothers and the law, consult our Infosheet Assisted procreation.
It depends. Remember that the biological father who offered to help with the “parental project” must agree from the onset that he will not be the baby’s father. However, the law gives the biological father who agreed to help with the “parental project” by having sex with one of the women, one year from the baby's birth to change his mind. The biological father can claim his filiation with the child by taking the appropriate steps before that year ends.
The law does not allow a sperm donor to claim his filiation with the child. Only the man who had sex is given this option. If the biological father decides to establish his filiation before the one year delay is up, the status of the same sex partner of the mother will be put into question. Remember that by law, a child can only have two parents.
In Quebec, the Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms forbids discrimination based on sexual orientation. The sexual orientation of the parents will therefore not be a valid reason to prevent same sex couples from adopting a child in Quebec.
However, this law does not apply outside the borders of Quebec. Foreign countries that have children available for adoption can therefore choose the type of parents that they are looking for in accordance with their own laws. Some countries exclude same sex couples. For more information, read our Infosheets entitled Adopting a child in Quebec and International adoption.
About the same subject
Éducaloi does not provide any legal advice or counseling. The information contained in its website constitutes a general source of information and does not in any way replace the services of a lawyer or notary.
|